Fontaines D.C. lost the Best Rock Album Grammy to The Rolling Stones’ Hackney Diamonds, sparking debate over whether the Grammys favor legacy artists, while the band acknowledged the loss with humor, questioning if younger rock acts can fairly compete in an industry that prioritizes nostalgia.

The 2025 Grammy Awards reignited a familiar debate—should legacy bands continue to dominate major music awards, or is it time for fresh talent to take the spotlight?

This question became especially relevant when Irish post-punk band Fontaines D.C. lost the Best Rock Album category to none other than The Rolling Stones.

Fontaines D.C., known for their raw energy, poetic lyricism, and modern take on punk-infused rock, had entered the Grammys as a formidable contender.

Their critically acclaimed album Romance had positioned them at the forefront of a new wave of rock bands proving that the genre is far from dead.

Yet, despite their meteoric rise and widespread praise, the Grammy went to Hackney Diamonds, the latest album from The Rolling Stones—a band that has defined rock music for over six decades.

For many, the result was predictable. The Grammys have long been accused of favoring legacy artists over new voices, often choosing to reward careers rather than the quality of specific albums.

While Hackney Diamonds was praised as a strong return to form for The Rolling Stones, many fans and critics questioned whether it truly represented the best rock album of the year—or whether the Grammys had simply defaulted to honoring a legendary name.

In the aftermath, Fontaines D.C. members Carlos O’Connell and Conor Curley addressed the loss with a mix of humor and realism.

Speaking in a radio interview, they admitted they weren’t entirely shocked by the result. “It’s a bit mad,” O’Connell said, acknowledging the weight of competing against a band as iconic as The Rolling Stones.

Curley, meanwhile, expressed a more pointed perspective: “I think the Grammys tend to give the award based on a band’s catalog rather than the actual record.”

O’Connell then joked that Fontaines D.C. might need to “turn 40” before they could actually win a Grammy, hinting at the long-standing pattern of the award show favoring older, more established acts.

The comments sparked widespread discussion online, with fans debating whether rock’s new generation is being given a fair shot in an industry that often prioritizes nostalgia over innovation.

Fontaines D.C. has quickly become one of the most exciting bands in rock today. Since their formation in Dublin in 2014, they have released a string of critically acclaimed albums that have not only resonated with rock purists but also introduced a younger audience to the power of post-punk.

Romance marked another evolution in their sound, blending moody introspection with explosive energy—earning them their second Grammy nomination after their 2021 nod for A Hero’s Death.

The band’s Grammy night wasn’t entirely without recognition. Their song Starburster was also nominated for Best Alternative Music Performance, further cementing their status as a major force in contemporary rock.

Though they walked away without a win, the nominations alone proved that their influence is growing, and their music is impossible to ignore.

On the other hand, The Rolling Stones’ victory reflects a broader industry trend. With Hackney Diamonds, the band delivered an album filled with high-profile collaborations and a return to their signature sound.

Featuring guest appearances from Paul McCartney, Lady Gaga, and Elton John, the album was designed as both a celebration of their legacy and a statement that, even after 60 years, they still have something to say.

For many fans, though, this raises an ongoing concern: when will the industry fully embrace the next wave of rock musicians?

While icons like The Rolling Stones undoubtedly deserve respect, younger bands are constantly fighting for recognition in a space still dominated by those who shaped it decades ago.

Fontaines D.C.’s response to their loss was as classy as it was revealing. They understand the industry, they know how the game is played, and they’re clearly in this for the long haul.

With an ever-growing fanbase and a sound that continues to evolve, it’s only a matter of time before they get their Grammy moment.

And when they do, it won’t be because of their legacy—it’ll be because they truly earned it.