In a seemingly innocuous photograph taken in 1857, two boys stand side by side on the porch of a grand Southern home.

One boy, dressed in an expensive suit, beams with the carefree joy of childhood, while the other, a Black child in slightly oversized formal attire, gazes at the camera with a profound awareness that belies his young age.

This image, discovered by Dr.Rebecca Morgan at Emory University, holds a dark secret that reveals the complexities of slavery and the resilience of the human spirit.

Dr.Morgan’s examination of the sepia-toned photograph led to a shocking revelation.

Upon closer inspection, she noticed a piece of paper partially visible at the feet of the Black child, later identified as Elijah.

It was a slave auction notice dated April 15, 1857, detailing the sale of “Healthy negro boy, Elijah, age 8.

” The photograph was taken just two days prior, marking the last documented moment of Elijah’s life before he was to be sold.

This discovery ignited a quest to uncover the story behind the photograph and, more importantly, what happened to Elijah after that fateful day.

 

Elijah’s story begins at Magnolia Creek Plantation, owned by the Harrison family.

Plantation records revealed financial struggles following the cotton blight of 1856, leading to the sale of enslaved individuals to cover debts.

Dr.Morgan’s research uncovered that Elijah was sold to James Fletcher of Charleston for $675.

The photograph’s composition, with the white child elevated above Elijah, was a stark reminder of the societal hierarchies entrenched in the South.

 

As Dr. Morgan delved deeper into the history, she discovered that the photographer, Frederick Simmons, had a unique relationship with the plantation owners.

While he documented their lives, he also sought to expose the brutal realities of slavery.

A letter in his records indicated that he sent images to an abolitionist newspaper in Boston, acknowledging the moral conflict he faced as he profited from photographing the very society he despised.

 

After being sold, Elijah found himself in the household of James Fletcher, where he was assigned as a houseboy to Mrs. Fletcher.

Remarkably, records indicated that Mrs.Fletcher was involved in a women’s reading society with Northern sympathies.

She recognized Elijah’s intelligence and began educating him in secret, a dangerous endeavor given the laws against teaching enslaved individuals to read and write.

This act of kindness was a stark contrast to the oppressive environment of slavery, and it provided Elijah with a glimmer of hope amidst his grim circumstances.

Elijah’s education progressed, and he became a companion to the Fletcher’s son, George.

This pairing of enslaved and owner’s children was common, but it was unusual for an enslaved child to receive formal education.

Mrs. Fletcher’s decision to teach both boys illustrated her quiet defiance against the norms of her time.

 

The outbreak of the Civil War in 1861 brought significant upheaval to Charleston.

As the war intensified, the Fletcher household faced financial difficulties, yet Mrs. Fletcher insisted on keeping Elijah despite the mounting pressures to sell him.

This decision underscored her commitment to his well-being, even as the threat of war loomed over them.

 

As the war progressed, Elijah’s position evolved from houseboy to personal servant to George.

His education expanded beyond basic literacy, and he began to display exceptional musical talent, surprising guests with his ability to play complex pieces on the pianoforte.

However, as Elijah grew older, the dangers associated with his education increased, particularly as suspicions of underground railroad activities arose.

 

In June 1862, a police report indicated that a “Negro boy approximately 13 years” was missing from the Fletcher household, suspected of being a runaway.

Elijah had escaped, and the circumstances surrounding his flight were shrouded in mystery.

Dr. Morgan’s investigation led her to records of underground railroad activities in Philadelphia, where she discovered that a young scholar fitting Elijah’s description had arrived via a maritime escape route.

This young scholar, identified only as “E,” showed remarkable aptitude and was receiving an education from a Quaker educator named Hannah Wells.

Wells’ records indicated that Elijah carried a photograph with him—one that depicted his life before freedom, serving as a reminder of the injustices he had endured.

 

Elijah’s journey did not end with his escape. He became an integral part of the underground railroad, using his knowledge of Charleston’s geography and shipping patterns to assist Union forces.

His contributions as a guide were invaluable, and he quickly became known for his bravery and intelligence.

 

By 1864, Elijah had transitioned from a fugitive to a respected figure within the Union army, earning commendations for his service.

His experiences during the war not only shaped his identity but also fueled his desire to document the narratives of those who had suffered under slavery.

 

After the war, Elijah Freeman returned to Charleston, now transformed by the defeat of the Confederacy.

He enrolled at a Freedman’s Bureau school, where he excelled academically and took on the role of a teaching assistant.

His application for further education in Northern institutions was supported by both Hannah Wells and Emily Fletcher, who had relocated to Philadelphia and expressed her regret for her previous actions.

 

Elijah’s acceptance into Oberlin College in Ohio marked a significant milestone in his life. At Oberlin, he studied education and history, becoming a voice for those who had been silenced.

His thesis focused on the use of visual documentation as a form of resistance against the narratives that had long oppressed Black individuals.

 

Throughout his life, Elijah Freeman dedicated himself to preserving the stories of formerly enslaved individuals.

He established the Freeman Historical Collection at Howard University, focusing on gathering personal narratives and photographs that reflected the experiences of African Americans.

His work was revolutionary, as it sought to counter the dominant narratives that romanticized the antebellum South.

Elijah returned to Charleston in 1885 to document the memories of those who had lived through slavery.

His field notes revealed a deep emotional connection to his past, as he reflected on the boy he once was and the man he had become.

He recognized the importance of preserving these stories for future generations, ensuring that the voices of the oppressed would not be forgotten.

 

The photograph that began this journey—a seemingly innocuous image of two boys—became a powerful symbol of resilience, transformation, and the enduring legacy of slavery.

Elijah Freeman’s life exemplified the strength of the human spirit in the face of unimaginable adversity.

Through his dedication to education, documentation, and empowerment, he transformed his painful past into a source of strength, ensuring that the stories of those who suffered would be remembered.

 

Dr. Rebecca Morgan’s research not only uncovered the life of Elijah Freeman but also highlighted the broader historical context of slavery and its aftermath.

As we reflect on Elijah’s journey, we are reminded of the importance of understanding our past and honoring the experiences of those who came before us.

Through the lens of history, we can find hope, resilience, and the promise of a better future.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.