In the spring of 2024, a remarkable photograph arrived at the Historical Photography Restoration Center in Boston, donated by the estate of Elellanena Hutchinson, who had lived to the age of 103.

Among countless images, one stood out—a seemingly ordinary Edwardian family portrait taken at the beach around 1905 or 1906.

But what initially appeared to be a charming snapshot of a family enjoying a summer day concealed a haunting secret: the mother’s eyes were not just closed—they had been carefully painted open.

Marcus, the senior conservator with over 20 years of experience, was called by his colleague Sarah to examine the photograph.

It showed nine people arranged casually on the sand: four adults standing behind, a seated woman in the center holding a small child, and several children scattered around.

The scene was typical of itinerant beach photographers who captured family moments at popular seaside resorts.

 

However, something about the seated woman caught their attention. Wearing a dark dress and an elaborate hat, her posture was unnaturally upright and still.

Most strikingly, her eyes—upon closer inspection under magnification—were not natural.

They were painted on, with delicate brush strokes creating the illusion of open eyes staring directly at the camera.

Beneath the paint, her actual eyelids were closed.

 

Marcus and Sarah realized this was a form of post-mortem photography, a practice common in the Victorian and Edwardian eras where deceased loved ones were photographed to memorialize them.

Typically, the deceased would be the clear focus, posed on a bed or chair with solemn family members arranged formally around them.

This photograph, however, was different. It depicted a casual beach outing, with relaxed poses and barefoot children smiling, giving no overt indication of death.

 

The woman’s painted eyes were an attempt to disguise the fact that she was dead.

This was not a typical memorial portrait but rather a family photograph taken after her death, intended to show the family as whole and complete.

 

Further research revealed the identity of the woman: Constance Ashworth of Cape May, New Jersey. She had died suddenly on August 10th, 1906, during a family holiday at the Lafayette Hotel.

The local newspaper reported her death as a heart seizure, though the circumstances were considered unusual.

 

The Ashworth family had planned their beach holiday for months. After Constance’s sudden passing in her hotel room during the night, the family faced a heartbreaking dilemma.

They had already scheduled a beach portrait with a photographer for the following day and had paid a deposit.

Unable to cancel or bear the thought of a family photo without their mother, they made a decision that was both macabre and touching.

 

On August 11th, the family dressed Constance in the same black dress and hat she had worn the day before.

With the help of the hotel physician and the understanding photographer, Mr.Thornton, they posed her body on the beach among her husband, children, and relatives.

The photographer skillfully painted open eyes on her closed eyelids to create the illusion that she was alive and present.

 

This technique was known in post-mortem photography but rarely used to conceal death in a casual family portrait.

The family wanted the photograph to look like a normal day at the beach, preserving the memory of their holiday as it should have been.

Examining the photograph closely reveals subtle signs of death disguised by love and grief. Constance’s posture is too perfect, her hands resting peacefully without tension.

Her skin, even through the aged sepia tones, has a waxy appearance unlike the living faces around her. The painted eyes, while skillfully done, betray the reality beneath.

 

Beside her sits a young boy, likely her son, with his hand resting gently on her arm.

Did he understand that his mother was no longer alive? The photograph captures a moment frozen between life and death, a family clinging to the illusion of togetherness.

 

A letter from Edmund Ashworth, Constance’s husband, reveals the emotional weight behind this act. He admitted that posing with his deceased wife was a lie, a deception born of grief.

The children deserved one last photograph of their mother, a final image of their family complete.

 

He described the photographer’s understanding and the painful preparations to make Constance appear alive for the portrait.

The letter expressed his conflicted feelings—knowing it was wrong, yet needing the comfort of that image to remember their family as they should have been.

 

The photograph now resides in the Cape May Historical Society’s collection, accompanied by documentation of Constance Ashworth’s death and the story behind the image.

It serves as an example of Victorian memorial photography techniques and the lengths to which families went to preserve memories in the face of loss.

 

To most viewers, it remains a charming beach scene, a family enjoying a summer day.

But for those who look closely, the painted eyes reveal a poignant truth: a mother who had died but was brought back to life, if only for a moment, through brush strokes and a family’s desperate refusal to let death erase their final holiday together.

This photograph embodies the complex relationship between death and memory in the early 20th century.

Photography, still a relatively new technology, offered families a way to hold onto their loved ones, even after death.

The Ashworth family’s choice to pose with Constance’s body reflects the human desire to deny loss and maintain a semblance of unity.

 

The painted eyes symbolize this denial—an artistic attempt to rewrite reality and offer comfort amid grief.

It challenges us to consider how we remember those who have passed and the lengths we go to preserve their presence in our lives.

 

The 1906 seaside portrait is more than a historical curiosity; it is a testament to love, loss, and the power of images to tell stories beyond the surface.

Constance Ashworth’s painted eyes stare out from the past, reminding us that behind every photograph lies a deeper narrative—sometimes beautiful, sometimes tragic, but always human.

 

For over a century, this family portrait has captured the imagination of those who see it, a silent witness to a father’s final gift to his children: one last moment frozen in time, where death was hidden beneath the brush strokes of hope and remembrance.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.