In the realm of historical photography, certain images capture not just the subjects they portray but also the untold stories hidden within their frames.

An 1859 portrait of the Asheford family from Richmond, Virginia, initially appears to be a typical representation of antebellum prosperity.

However, a closer examination reveals a profound narrative of resistance and resilience, centered around an enslaved woman named Clara, who held a secret in her hand that would change the understanding of her history and that of countless others.

Dr.Sarah Mitchell, a historian at the Virginia Historical Society, found herself captivated by a daguerreotype of the Asheford family that arrived in an unmarked box.

The photograph depicted Master Jonathan Asheford, his wife, and their three children posed on the steps of their plantation manor, with five enslaved servants standing in the background.

At first glance, the image seemed to reflect the wealth and social standing of the Asheford family. However, something about the posture of one servant caught Sarah’s eye.

 

This woman, standing slightly apart from the others, held a piece of paper tightly in her right hand, partially obscured by the folds of her dress.

This detail was unusual; in hundreds of plantation photographs Sarah had studied, enslaved individuals were typically depicted as passive background figures, devoid of agency.

Intrigued, Sarah began to investigate further, realizing that this seemingly innocuous piece of paper might hold significant meaning.

 

After examining the photograph, Sarah researched the Asheford family and discovered that Jonathan Asheford owned a tobacco plantation called Riverside Manor, employing 47 enslaved workers in 1859.

He was a respected member of Richmond society, involved in local politics and church activities.

The daguerreotype was taken by Marcus Webb, a traveling photographer known for documenting wealthy families in Virginia during this period.

 

As Sarah delved deeper into the Asheford family records, she uncovered a letter from Jonathan written in September 1859, just a month after the photograph was taken.

In it, he expressed concern about “troubling incidents” among the house servants, indicating that he had increased their supervision due to fears of “notions” spreading among them.

This revelation suggested that something significant had transpired within the household, prompting Jonathan to take drastic measures.

Further investigation led Sarah to Elizabeth Ashford Monroe, a descendant of the Asheford family.

Elizabeth shared family stories that hinted at a troubling incident in 1859 involving a woman named Clara, who was known for her intelligence and literacy.

Clara had reportedly taught herself to read by stealing books, a dangerous act in an era when literacy was often forbidden for enslaved individuals.

Jonathan discovered Clara’s activities and subsequently sold her along with two other women, fearing they posed a threat to his authority.

 

Elizabeth’s great-great-grandmother, Margaret Asheford, had kept a journal that included references to the family portrait and noted Clara’s unusual demeanor during the sitting.

The entries suggested that Clara’s actions were not merely those of a compliant servant but rather someone aware of the larger social dynamics at play.

 

Sarah’s research took a pivotal turn when she contacted Dr. James Washington, an expert on enslaved resistance movements.

He highlighted the significance of the timing surrounding the photograph, noting that John Brown’s raid on Harper’s Ferry occurred just two months later.

This event intensified fears among slaveholders and may have prompted Jonathan Asheford’s decision to sell Clara and her companions.

 

As Sarah pieced together the timeline, she began to suspect that the paper Clara held in the photograph might contain information related to the Underground Railroad, a network of secret routes and safe houses used by enslaved people to escape to free states.

If Clara was indeed involved in such activities, the implications of her presence in the photograph were profound.

 

Determined to uncover the truth, Sarah traveled to New Orleans, where Clara had been sold.

At the Amistad Research Center, she found records confirming that Clara, along with two other women, had been sold to a sugar plantation owner.

Notably, one of the documents referred to Clara as having unusual scarring on her hands, which could indicate punishment for her literacy efforts.

 

Sarah’s investigation continued in Philadelphia, where she examined Quaker records related to the Underground Railroad.

She discovered correspondence that suggested a woman with connections to Virginia was actively aiding escapees.

This woman exhibited remarkable intelligence and was described as possessing vital information about networks in Virginia.

The breakthrough came when Sarah and her colleagues used advanced imaging technology to analyze the original daguerreotype.

They discovered that the paper Clara held was not just folded; it bore marks that suggested it contained writing.

With further enhancement, they revealed what appeared to be a crude map, possibly indicating safe houses and contacts within the Underground Railroad network.

 

The symbols on the map corresponded with known codes used by abolitionists, suggesting that Clara was documenting a network of resistance.

This revelation transformed the understanding of the photograph from a mere depiction of a wealthy family to a testament of Clara’s courage and determination to fight against oppression.

 

Clara’s story did not end with her sale to Louisiana.

Sarah uncovered evidence that Clara escaped and returned to Virginia, where she became an active conductor on the Underground Railroad.

Reports from the Civil War era indicated that Clara was aiding runaways while evading capture.

Her intelligence and connections allowed her to support others seeking freedom, effectively turning the very place of her enslavement into a site of liberation.

The culmination of Sarah’s research was showcased in an exhibition at the Virginia Historical Society, where the 1859 daguerreotype now hung with a new narrative.

The photograph was no longer just a symbol of antebellum power; it represented the resilience of those who fought against it.

 

The story of Clara, as revealed through the daguerreotype, serves as a powerful reminder of the complexities of history.

It challenges the narrative that enslaved individuals were mere victims, instead highlighting their agency and resistance.

Clara’s deliberate inclusion of a map in a formal portrait is a testament to the creativity and courage of those who sought freedom against overwhelming odds.

 

As descendants of both the Asheford family and those who were enslaved come together to honor Clara’s legacy, the photograph stands not only as a historical artifact but as a symbol of hope and resilience.

It reminds us that history is often more intricate than it appears, and that the stories of those who resisted oppression deserve to be told and celebrated.

Clara’s journey from an enslaved woman to a conductor on the Underground Railroad is a powerful narrative of transformation, courage, and the enduring fight for freedom.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.