On September 20, 2017, the vibrant life of 19-year-old Karina Slusser took a dark turn that would leave her family and law enforcement bewildered and searching for answers.

A seemingly ordinary phone call to her mother, Sabina Toardo, marked the last time anyone heard from Karina.

What transpired in the days leading up to her disappearance reveals a troubling narrative about vulnerability, exploitation, and the dangers lurking in the digital age.

Karina was in Queens, New York, when she called her mother, who was in Florida attending her father’s funeral.

During this call, Karina expressed her urgent desire to return home to Bloomsburg, Pennsylvania.

She mentioned that her driver’s license and social security card had been stolen, leaving her unable to purchase a plane ticket.

Her voice trembled with anxiety, hinting at an underlying distress that Sabina could sense but could not decipher.

 

Despite her mother’s encouragement to stay safe in the hotel until she could return, Karina’s situation was more precarious than it appeared.

That evening, she reached out to a man named Yavani Pagarro, seeking shelter and assistance.

However, by the time he replied three hours later, Karina had vanished without a trace. This marked the beginning of a complex investigation into her mysterious disappearance.

 

Karina Slusser was born on March 6, 1998, and grew up in a loving household, raised by her mother after her parents’ divorce.

Known for her outgoing personality, she excelled academically and actively participated in school activities, including cheerleading.

She maintained an Instagram account filled with images showcasing her aspirations of becoming a makeup artist, projecting an image of confidence and ambition.

However, as she entered her late teens, warning signs began to emerge.

In 2016, Karina shifted her friend circle, began skipping classes, and fell under the influence of a new crowd.

This led to her arrest for petty theft, marking the beginning of a downward spiral that would culminate in her tragic disappearance.

 

By spring 2017, Karina was in the grips of a severe mental and emotional crisis. After a troubling incident involving self-harm, she was hospitalized.

Upon her release, she sought a fresh start by moving in with a friend in Hazelton, Pennsylvania, where she found work as a server.

However, her desire for easy money soon led her down a dangerous path.

 

Karina began associating with men who provided her with gifts and cash, identifying herself as a “sugar baby.

” Initially perceived as a means of boosting her self-esteem, this lifestyle quickly spiraled into dependency.

Her financial instability worsened, leading to conflicts with her friend and ultimately leaving her homeless.

 

Sabina’s attempts to warn her daughter about the dangers of this lifestyle were met with anger and resistance. Despite presenting a curated image on social media, the reality of Karina’s life was fraught with instability and risk.

By the summer of 2017, she was entrenched in a chaotic existence, marked by financial struggles and a growing reliance on online connections with men who preyed on vulnerable young women.

In August 2017, Karina connected with 32-year-old Yoani Pagarro, who promised her a new life in New York City.

With hopes of escaping her troubles, Karina arrived in New York on August 19, where Pagarro met her and took her to the Harlem Vista Hotel.

Initially, he provided for her needs, but it soon became clear that his intentions were far from benevolent.

 

As days passed, Pagarro exerted increasing control over Karina’s life. He dictated her communications, monitored her phone, and isolated her from friends and family.

Tensions escalated, culminating in an incident of violence on August 25, when Pagarro assaulted Karina over money he had stolen from her.

After this incident, Karina reported him to the police, leading to his arrest.

 

However, even after Pagarro’s arrest, Karina found herself in a precarious situation. Without her identification documents and financial resources, she was left vulnerable and isolated.

Her relationship with her mother had deteriorated to the point where returning home was not an option.

 

In the days following her assault, Karina’s situation deteriorated further.

She began seeking temporary shelter through online platforms, meeting men who offered her a place to stay in exchange for companionship.

Despite maintaining an upbeat façade on social media, she was increasingly trapped in a web of exploitation.

By September 20, 2017, Karina was last seen leaving the Haven Motel in Queens.

Surveillance footage confirmed her presence, but after that day, she vanished without a trace.

Her absence went unnoticed for several days, as her chaotic lifestyle made her silence seem unremarkable to those who knew her.

 

When Sabina returned from her father’s funeral and discovered her daughter was missing, she contacted the police.

Initially, the case was treated as a voluntary departure, but Sabina’s insistence on the circumstances surrounding Karina’s life prompted a deeper investigation.

 

As investigators delved into Karina’s disappearance, they uncovered a troubling network of individuals connected to Pagarro and a man named Isaiah Icy Homer.

Evidence suggested that Karina had been drawn into a world of human trafficking, where vulnerable young women were exploited for profit.

 

Despite the mounting evidence, the investigation faced significant challenges. Karina was legally an adult, and without concrete proof of foul play, law enforcement struggled to take decisive action.

Sabina, undeterred, became the voice for her daughter, raising awareness and seeking justice through social media and public outreach.

In December 2017, the FBI announced a $10,000 reward for information about Karina’s whereabouts.

Sabina’s relentless efforts led to increased media attention, shining a light on the dangers of online exploitation and the systemic issues that allowed such cases to occur.

 

By 2022, the investigation culminated in charges against Isaiah Icy Homer for human trafficking and exploitation.

Although Karina’s case remained officially unsolved, her story became emblematic of the vulnerabilities faced by young women in the digital age.

 

Despite the legal victories, for Sabina, the pain of not knowing what happened to her daughter remained.

Karina’s disappearance serves as a haunting reminder of the dangers that exist in a world where the lines between online connections and real-life consequences can blur dangerously.

 

The tragic story of Karina Slusser underscores the importance of vigilance and awareness in today’s digital landscape.

It highlights the need for stronger protections for vulnerable individuals and the critical role that families and communities play in safeguarding their loved ones.

As Sabina continues to advocate for her daughter, her journey reflects the broader fight against human trafficking and exploitation, reminding us that every missing person is more than just a statistic—they are loved ones waiting to be found.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.