Kristin Cavallari’s claim that she “never got a penny” from ex-husband Jay Cutler after their divorce sparked headlines, but Cutler swiftly denied it, insisting the settlement was “definitely not zero dollars” — reigniting tensions in their already dramatic split and leaving fans stunned by the messy truth behind their breakup.

The fallout from Kristin Cavallari and Jay Cutler’s highly publicized divorce continues to unfold, and this time it’s the former NFL quarterback pushing back against his ex-wife’s version of events.

Cavallari, 38, known for her role on Laguna Beach and later her lifestyle empire under Uncommon James, recently made headlines when she declared she “never got a penny” from Cutler, despite his successful 12-season career with the Chicago Bears.

The remark, which she shared during a candid discussion about her post-divorce life, quickly fueled speculation about just how bitter the financial settlement between the exes might have been.

But Jay Cutler, 42, isn’t letting that statement go unchallenged.

In a new interview, the retired quarterback firmly denied Cavallari’s claim and made it clear that her account wasn’t entirely accurate.

“I can guarantee you it’s definitely not zero dollars,” Cutler said with a pointed calmness, stopping short of providing any dollar amounts or details of the financial arrangements.

The couple, who married in 2013 after a whirlwind romance that began in 2010, share three children together: Camden, 13, Jaxon, 11, and Saylor, 9.

When they announced their divorce in April 2020 after seven years of marriage, both emphasized their “deep love and respect” for each other in public statements.

But as time passed, the cracks in that amicable façade became more apparent, with rumors of disputes over custody, assets, and lifestyle choices surfacing.

Cavallari, who has spoken openly about wanting her independence post-split, previously admitted she felt “stifled” in her marriage and described the divorce as one of the most difficult yet liberating experiences of her life.

On her podcast, she shared: “I didn’t want to be in a relationship where I lost myself.

Walking away was the hardest thing I’ve ever done, but it was also the bravest.”

It was during one of these recent reflections on her journey that Cavallari dropped the line about never receiving financial support from Cutler — a remark that now, thanks to his rebuttal, is stirring fresh debate.

Some fans interpreted Cavallari’s words as a metaphor for emotional support, while others believed she was being literal, accusing Cutler of withholding money despite his lucrative NFL earnings.

Cutler’s simple, measured response, however, strongly suggests that a financial settlement was in fact made, though he has chosen not to publicize the details.

The lack of clarity has only fueled curiosity.

Divorce settlements in high-profile marriages like theirs often involve millions in assets, from luxury homes to business ventures.

Cavallari’s Uncommon James brand, founded in 2017, has grown into a multimillion-dollar company, while Cutler reportedly earned over $120 million in salary during his NFL career.

Untangling such finances is rarely straightforward, and it’s likely the pair agreed to keep many details private for the sake of their children.

Still, the public nature of their back-and-forth comments has reignited interest in the relationship that once fascinated fans of reality TV and football alike.

From their on-and-off engagement drama in the early 2010s to their glossy social media presence during the height of their marriage, Cavallari and Cutler’s union was anything but ordinary.

Even now, years after their separation, the two seem to remain linked in the public eye.

Cavallari has recently been spotted enjoying a new chapter of her life, embracing single motherhood while also stepping back into the dating world.

Cutler, meanwhile, has shifted away from the spotlight, occasionally surfacing on podcasts and interviews where he offers glimpses into his post-NFL lifestyle.

What remains clear is that neither seems particularly interested in burying the narrative — if anything, their opposing accounts of what happened financially only add more intrigue to their already complicated history.

As one source close to the pair put it, “Kristin and Jay will always be connected because of their kids, but their relationship has always had tension.

This latest back-and-forth isn’t surprising to anyone who knows them.”

For fans who followed Cavallari’s journey from Laguna Beach to The Hills and then to Very Cavallari, the continued drama with Cutler is both messy and captivating.

For Cutler’s longtime supporters in Chicago and beyond, his quiet yet deliberate clapback reminds them of the man who rarely showed his emotions on the field but always made sure to deliver when it mattered.

Whether Cavallari clarifies her “not a penny” comment in light of Cutler’s rebuttal remains to be seen.

But one thing is certain — even after divorce, this former golden couple knows how to keep people talking.