Fans of Sarah Jessica Parker’s character Carrie Bradshaw are torn between admiration for the lavish tour of her stunning Gramercy Park townhouse in “And Just Like That” and disappointment in the show’s current storyline, sparking a debate about whether the focus on extravagant set design overshadows the character’s relatable struggles and emotional depth.

In a stunning behind-the-scenes tour that has fans buzzing, HBO Max has unveiled the opulent four-story townhouse of Carrie Bradshaw, played by Sarah Jessica Parker, from the series “And Just Like That.

” Located in the upscale Gramercy Park neighborhood of Manhattan, this lavish property, steeped in history since its construction in 1846, showcases a Greek revival-style architecture that reflects the character’s extravagant lifestyle.

However, fans were quick to realize that this glamorous setting is actually a meticulously crafted soundstage, raising eyebrows about the authenticity of the show’s production.

Production designer Miguel Lopez Castillo and set decorator Karin Wiesel Holmes provided Architectural Digest with an exclusive look into Carrie’s world, revealing details that sparked nostalgia among long-time fans.

One of the highlights of the tour was Carrie’s shoe closet, a separate space dedicated to her extensive collection of footwear, which includes iconic pieces like the silver Manolo Blahnik ‘D’Orsay’ heels. This particular pair has become synonymous with Bradshaw’s character, symbolizing her love for fashion and luxury.

As viewers recall, Carrie’s journey has been marked by memorable moments, such as the emotional finale of “Sex and the City,” where she famously rediscovered her Carrie necklace after a tumultuous relationship with Russian artist Alexandr Petrovsky, played by Mikhail Baryshnikov.

The show’s fans fondly remember how she navigated complex relationships, particularly with Mr. Big, portrayed by Chris Noth, who remains a central figure in her life.

The tour also featured Carrie’s repurposed ballet costume from the series finale, a nostalgic nod to her character’s artistic roots and the show’s rich history.

Fans were treated to a glimpse of a black-and-white wingtip-style Maison Margiela ‘Bourgeoise Spectator Tabi’ pump, which Carrie wore during a Tiffany & Co. event in the latest season, further connecting the character’s past with her present.

However, while the lavish set design captured the attention of many, it also sparked a wave of criticism regarding the current direction of the show.

On AD’s official Instagram account, user @silvanogon expressed disappointment, stating, “This show is horrible now. The only thing saving it is this beautiful home.

Thank you!” This sentiment was echoed by others who feel that the storyline has not lived up to the high standards set by its predecessor, “Sex and the City.”

User @berzinsky pointed out the lack of furniture in the expansive home, commenting, “Not a single sofa in an enormous house. The symbolism is real – she will never share her life and will die alone.

” This critique reflects a broader concern among fans that the character’s evolution has strayed too far from the relatable struggles that initially endeared her to audiences.

In contrast, some fans remain steadfast in their love for the series, with user @mia_lips showcasing her dedication by identifying a Gucci envelope clutch from a specific episode in season five when Carrie rings the bell at the Stock Exchange.

“I can’t believe I noticed that. SATC forever! It’s my comfort show,” she remarked, highlighting the deep connection many viewers still feel towards the franchise.

On YouTube, the discussion continued with user @valleygirl2530, who appreciated the production quality but lamented the lack of compelling plotlines, stating, “If only the plot, dialogue, cast, and acting were on the same level!” This critique encapsulates the frustration felt by many fans who find themselves torn between their affection for the original series and their disappointment with its reboot.

As the debate rages on, the lavishness of Carrie Bradshaw’s Gramercy Park home serves as a backdrop for a larger conversation about the direction of storytelling in modern television.

While the set design dazzles, fans are left wondering if the heart of the series—the relatable struggles of love, friendship, and self-discovery—has been lost in the pursuit of glamour.

With the show continuing to air, viewers are eager to see if the creators will listen to fan feedback and recalibrate the narrative to recapture the magic that made “Sex and the City” a cultural phenomenon. As the saga unfolds, one thing is clear: fans are watching closely, and their voices are shaping the future of this iconic series.