Rachel Zegler’s Career Crisis: Snow White Fallout and the London Stage Failure

Rachel Zegler’s rise to fame was meteoric, but her fall has been equally swift and public.

After being handpicked by Steven Spielberg for the lead role in West Side Story, Zegler was positioned as Hollywood’s next big thing.

What followed, however, has been a series of missteps and controversies, culminating in the disastrous performance of Disney’s live-action Snow White and the underwhelming reception of her latest stage project, Evita, at London’s prestigious Palladium.

The financial and critical failure of Snow White marked a significant turning point in Zegler’s career.

Despite a budget reportedly exceeding $300 million due to extensive reshoots, the film has struggled to recoup its costs, with global box office earnings hovering around $200 million.

When factoring in marketing expenses, Disney is estimated to have lost nearly $200 million on the project.

While Zegler’s performance was not the sole reason for the film’s failure—critics largely blamed poor writing and misguided creative decisions—her pre-release comments about the original Snow White alienated fans and created a PR nightmare.

Dismissing the 1937 classic as “creepy” and criticizing the prince as “stalkerish,” Zegler inadvertently set the stage for backlash before the film even hit theaters.

The fallout from Snow White has been compounded by the lukewarm reception of Zegler’s latest endeavor: starring as Eva Perón in Evita at the London Palladium.

Despite the high-profile nature of the production, ticket sales have been dismal.

According to reports, entire performances remain wide open, with a traffic light system on the ticketing website showing green for nearly every seat.

This lack of audience interest is particularly damning in the world of theater, where ticket sales often reflect a performer’s ability to draw a crowd.

In stark contrast, other productions running concurrently, such as John Lithgow’s show, have seen much higher demand, underscoring Zegler’s apparent inability to connect with audiences.

This troubling trend raises questions about Zegler’s star power—or lack thereof.

While her talent is undeniable, her career trajectory highlights a fundamental disconnect between Hollywood’s star-making apparatus and audience preferences.

Studios have repeatedly thrust Zegler into massive, high-budget productions without allowing her to build a foundation of smaller, well-received roles.

This aggressive approach has positioned her as the face of commercial failures, creating a narrative about her bankability that may be difficult to overcome.

The situation is reminiscent of other actors whom Hollywood has unsuccessfully tried to mold into stars.

Names like Jai Courtney and Sam Worthington come to mind—performers who were repeatedly cast in major blockbusters despite lukewarm audience reception.

Zegler’s case, however, is particularly striking because of the sheer scale of the projects she has been attached to.

From West Side Story to Snow White and now Evita, each failure has added to the perception that she lacks the drawing power studios had hoped for.

Adding to the complexity of Zegler’s predicament is the broader shift in audience behavior.

Traditional star power no longer guarantees success in the way it once did.

Modern audiences are more drawn to compelling stories, strong franchises, and quality filmmaking than to the names on the marquee.

This shift has made it increasingly difficult for emerging talents to establish themselves as bankable stars, especially when they are thrust into the spotlight prematurely.

Despite these challenges, Zegler’s career is not without hope.

Hollywood has a long history of redemption stories, and many argue that she has the talent to bounce back if given the right opportunities.

A more measured approach to her career—focusing on smaller, critically acclaimed projects rather than massive blockbusters—could help rebuild her credibility with audiences and critics alike.

For example, taking on supporting roles in independent films or ensemble casts could allow her to demonstrate her range without bearing the full weight of a project’s success or failure.

The entertainment industry, however, may not be so forgiving.

Studios are notoriously risk-averse, and the financial losses associated with Snow White and the poor ticket sales for Evita are likely to make executives hesitant to cast Zegler in leading roles.

While there has been no official blacklisting, the quiet adjustment of casting decisions—where her name is simply left off shortlists for major projects—could effectively stall her career.

The broader implications of Zegler’s situation extend beyond her individual career.

Her struggles highlight the flaws in Hollywood’s current approach to developing new stars.

The industry’s reliance on massive, high-stakes projects to launch careers often sets actors up for failure, especially in an era where audience loyalty must be earned rather than assumed.

Successful young actors like Florence Pugh, Timothée Chalamet, and Zendaya have followed a more organic path, mixing smaller, critically acclaimed films with strategic mainstream projects.

This balanced approach has allowed them to build genuine connections with audiences and establish themselves as reliable box office draws.

In contrast, Zegler’s career has been characterized by an accelerated star-making process that has left little room for organic growth.

Her early successes, while impressive, have been overshadowed by the high-profile failures that followed.

This pattern has not only damaged her reputation but also underscored the risks of Hollywood’s increasingly unsustainable reliance on manufactured stardom.

As Zegler faces the next chapter of her career, the path forward is uncertain.

Her upcoming projects, including her role in The Hunger Games: The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes, may provide an opportunity for redemption.

However, even this project relies heavily on the established popularity of the Hunger Games franchise, rather than Zegler’s individual star power.

Whether she can leverage this opportunity to rebuild her career remains to be seen.

Ultimately, the story of Rachel Zegler serves as a cautionary tale for both Hollywood and aspiring actors.

It is a reminder that true stardom cannot be manufactured overnight.

It must be earned through consistent quality work, a genuine connection with audiences, and a measured approach to career development.

For Zegler, the road to redemption will require humility, resilience, and a willingness to learn from past mistakes.

Only time will tell if she can navigate these challenges and reclaim her place in the spotlight.

Until then, the industry—and audiences—will be watching closely.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.