I.A Portrait That Hid a Secret

On August 23, 1895, at Miller’s photography studio in Boston, a nine-year-old girl named Eleanor Hayes stood for her portrait.

She wore a dark dress with a white collar, her hair neatly braided, and she held a large black umbrella—not open, but resting against her shoulder like a walking stick.

The photographer, James Miller, made a simple note in his ledger: “Portrait of Miss Eleanor Hayes, paid by St.

Catherine’s Home for Children, destination Western Placement Program.”

For 124 years, the photograph sat in the archives of Boston Children’s Services, one of thousands of orphan portraits taken before children were sent west on “orphan trains”—a system that relocated over 200,000 children between 1854 and 1929.

The image seemed unremarkable: a serious child, formally dressed, holding an umbrella.

But in 2019, digital conservator Dr.

Lisa Chen examined the photo at 14,000% magnification.

She discovered something hidden in plain sight—something carved into the umbrella’s handle that transformed this image from a simple orphan portrait into a devastating story of loss, love, and a father’s final gift.

 

II.

The Orphan and the Umbrella

Eleanor Hayes arrived at St.

Catherine’s Home for Children on July 15, 1895.

She was nine, thin, quiet, and fiercely attached to a black umbrella that dwarfed her small frame.

The intake records, preserved in the archive, read:

> Eleanor Marie Hayes, age 9 years, 4 months.

> Father, William Hayes, deceased June 30, 1895.

Industrial accident, lumber mill.

> Mother, Katherine Hayes, deceased January 12, 1891.

Tuberculosis.

> No living relatives willing to provide care.

> Possessions: One dress (worn), one pair of shoes (poor condition), one umbrella (good condition, adult male’s).

Child extremely attached to umbrella.

Matron notes: Child refuses to relinquish umbrella even for sleeping.

Recommend allowing possession as comfort item.

Industrial accidents were common in 1895 Boston.

William Hayes worked at the Sawyer Lumber Mill, operating a circular saw.

On June 30, a belt snapped and the saw kicked back.

William was killed instantly at 34, leaving behind Eleanor, who had already lost her mother four years earlier to tuberculosis.

After Katherine’s death, William raised Eleanor alone, working 12-hour days for $14 a week—enough to rent a small apartment, keep Eleanor in school, and feed and clothe her.

His sister Margaret helped when she could, but with six children of her own and a husband who drank, she couldn’t take Eleanor in after William’s death.

The city’s solution was St.

Catherine’s—a Catholic orphanage that housed about 200 children at any time.

It was clean, well-run, but never meant to be permanent.

Children stayed a few weeks before being sent west on orphan trains—relocated to rural communities where they’d be placed with families who needed extra labor.

The system was presented as charitable, but in reality, many children became unpaid farmhands or domestic servants.

Eleanor was scheduled for the orphan train departing Boston on August 26, just three days after her portrait was taken.

Each child was photographed before departure—a record for the orphanage, a tool for placement, and sometimes the only memento a child would keep from their old life.

 

III.

The Photograph: A Moment of Defiance

James Miller, the contract photographer, had documented hundreds of orphans.

Most arrived with nothing but the clothes they wore.

But Eleanor came with her umbrella.

The matron explained, “It was her father’s.

She won’t let it go.

We’ve tried, but she becomes hysterical.” The mother superior allowed Eleanor to keep it for the photograph.

“She’ll have to leave it behind when she boards the train—children are allowed only one small bag—but for now, let her hold it.”

James positioned Eleanor in front of a plain backdrop.

“Hold the umbrella against your shoulder like this,” he instructed.

“Look at the camera.

Try to look pleasant, dear.

This photograph might be the first thing your new family sees.”

Eleanor did as she was told, but she didn’t look pleasant.

She looked terrified.

The session lasted 15 minutes; Eleanor was the seventh child photographed that day.

Standard fee: 25 cents per child.

Each received a simple portrait, hands visible, face clearly shown, formal attire.

No props were usually allowed.

Eleanor’s umbrella was the exception.

James wrote in his notes, “She wouldn’t put it down.

The matron said it belonged to her deceased father and was her only possession from her former life.

I positioned her holding it against her shoulder, standing formal pose.

The child appeared deeply unhappy but compliant.

Exposure time 12 seconds.

One plate only.”

Twelve seconds was a long time for a nine-year-old to remain still.

Any movement would blur the image.

Eleanor stood frozen, holding the umbrella, staring at the camera with an expression James later described as “profound resignation.”

Afterward, the matron took Eleanor’s hand.

“Can I keep it?” Eleanor asked, clutching the umbrella.

“Can I bring it on the train?”

“No, dear,” the matron said gently.

“The train only allows one small bag.

You’ll have a change of clothes and a Bible.

That’s all.

The umbrella is too large.

It will have to stay at St.

Catherine’s.”

“But it was Papa’s,” Eleanor whispered.

“It’s all I have.”

“Your new family will provide everything you need.

You won’t need an old umbrella.”

But Eleanor understood what the matron didn’t.

The umbrella wasn’t about rain.

It was about connection—the last thing her father had touched, the last link to her parents and her past.

 

IV.

The Object Left Behind

The orphan train system was designed to sever connections.

Children were often given new names, discouraged from talking about their pasts, told to be grateful for new opportunities and forget the families they’d lost.

Eleanor boarded the train with one small cloth bag: a change of clothes, undergarments, a nightgown, a Bible, and her photograph.

The umbrella was left behind, stored in the orphanage’s property room with other items too large or impractical for children to take.

Most were never reclaimed and eventually sold or discarded.

Eleanor’s umbrella likely met that fate.

But the photograph survived—filed in St.

Catherine’s records, transferred to Boston Children’s Services when the orphanage closed in 1947, then to the Massachusetts State Archives in 1983.

For 124 years, it was simply “orphan portrait, girl with umbrella, 1895, unknown destination.”

 

V.

Discovery in the Digital Age

In 2019, Dr.

Lisa Chen began work on a digital preservation project with the Massachusetts State Archives.

The goal: scan and catalog 15,000 orphan train-era photographs, creating a database to help descendants trace their family histories.

“The photographs were in surprisingly good condition,” Lisa explained in a 2020 interview.

“My job was to scan them at high resolution, high enough to see tiny details like the weave of fabric or individual strands of hair.”

Lisa scanned Eleanor’s photograph in March 2019.

At standard resolution, it showed exactly what the archive described—a young girl in a dark dress holding a large umbrella in a photography studio.

But Lisa’s protocol required examination at multiple magnification levels—2,000%, 5,000%, 10,000%, and finally 14,000%.

At 2,000%, she examined Eleanor’s face: serious, sad, resigned.

At 5,000%, the dress: simple, dark, well-worn.

At 10,000%, the background: plain studio backdrop.

At 14,000%, Lisa examined the umbrella.

That’s when she saw it.

The umbrella’s handle, where Eleanor’s right hand gripped tightly, had been carved—not decoratively, but deliberately.

Letters, initials.

Lisa adjusted the contrast and sharpness.

The letters became clearer: WH—William Hayes, Eleanor’s father.

Below, a date: 1890.

And below that, a single word: Ellie.

Lisa sat back, hands shaking.

This wasn’t just an umbrella.

This was a father’s umbrella, carved with his initials, the year, and his daughter’s nickname.

Through death, orphaning, and 124 years of storage, that umbrella had survived long enough to be photographed—preserving the only evidence that William Hayes had loved his daughter enough to carve her name into his most valued possession.

 

VI.

Piecing Together Eleanor’s Story

Lisa dove into research.

She found William Hayes’s death certificate: age 34, died June 30, 1895, industrial accident, lumber mill worker.

His wife’s death certificate: Catherine Marie Hayes, age 29, died January 12, 1891, tuberculosis.

Eleanor’s birth certificate: born April 15, 1886, parents William and Catherine Hayes.

St.

Catherine’s intake records confirmed Eleanor’s arrival on July 15, 1895.

The orphan train manifest showed her departure August 26, 1895, destination Kansas, assigned to a farming family in Sedgwick County.

But after that, Eleanor vanished.

The orphan train system was notoriously poor at follow-up.

Children were placed with families, sometimes adopted, sometimes kept as laborers.

Many lost their original surnames and contact with their origins.

Lisa realized the significance of the carved umbrella handle.

William Hayes had carved it in 1890, a year before his wife died.

The umbrella was an artifact from when Eleanor’s family was whole.

Dr.

Margaret Patterson, a historian, explained: “Umbrellas were significant for working-class families.

They weren’t cheap—a good umbrella cost about $2, nearly 15% of a week’s wages.

A man might own one his entire life.

Carving your initials was a way of marking ownership and personalizing it.

Adding ‘Ellie,’ his daughter’s nickname, was an act of love.”

When William died, his possessions were minimal.

His clothes, work tools, a few coins, and his umbrella.

Margaret, his sister, gave the umbrella to Eleanor.

“This was your papa’s.

He carried it every day.

When it rained, he’d open it and say, ‘Ellie’s umbrella is keeping us dry today.’ He loved you very much.”

Eleanor, newly orphaned for the second time, clutched the umbrella like a lifeline.

Two weeks later, when Margaret explained she couldn’t keep her, Eleanor packed her few belongings and the umbrella.

At the orphanage, matrons tried to take it away.

“You don’t need such a large item,” they said.

But Eleanor wouldn’t let go.

She slept with it.

She carried it everywhere.

Eventually, the staff allowed her to keep it—until the orphan train departed.

 

VII.

The Orphan Train: Loss and Survival

Eleanor boarded the orphan train from Boston’s South Station on August 26, 1895, with 43 children aged 3 to 14.

The journey to Kansas took four days.

At each stop, children were presented to potential families who inspected them and chose whom to take home.

By the time the train reached Wichita, Kansas, on August 30, Eleanor was one of 17 children still waiting for placement.

At the First Presbyterian Church, she was chosen by Jacob and Harriet Mueller, German immigrants with a wheat farm in Sedgwick County.

They had no children and needed help with the farm and household duties.

“Can she work?” Jacob asked.

“She’s nine, healthy, can read and do basic arithmetic,” the agent replied.

“Good.

We’ll take her.”

No questions about Eleanor’s personality.

No conversation with her.

Just, “We’ll take her.”

Eleanor left the church with the Muellers.

She never returned to Boston.

She never saw her father’s umbrella again.

But she kept a secret: the night before boarding the train, she’d hidden in the orphanage kitchen and cut off a piece of the umbrella handle—just the part with “Ellie” carved into it.

She hid it in her bag.

Nobody knew.

She kept it with her for years.

 

VIII.

The Carved Wood: A Legacy Carried Forward

Years later, in 1943, Eleanor told her granddaughter about that piece of wood.

“I couldn’t bring Papa’s umbrella on the train.

They made me leave it.

But I cut off the part with my name.

I kept it for years.”

Lisa found more records.

In the 1900 census: Eleanor Mueller, age 14, daughter, Kansas.

She had been adopted by the Muellers and taken their surname.

In 1910: Eleanor Mueller, age 24, married to Frank Sullivan, a farmer.

By 1920, Eleanor and Frank had four children: William (named after her father), Catherine (her mother), Ruth, and James.

In 1918, Eleanor registered for a World War I women’s auxiliary and listed her birth name as Eleanor Hayes—proof she never forgot her original identity.

Lisa found Eleanor’s great-granddaughter, Jennifer Sullivan Brooks, living in Topeka, Kansas.

“I knew my great-grandmother had been an orphan train rider,” Jennifer said.

“She said she came from Boston, that both parents had died, and she’d been sent west at nine.

Did she ever mention her father’s umbrella?” Lisa asked.

“Yes,” Jennifer replied.

“She kept a small piece of carved wood in her jewelry box.

She said it was from her father’s umbrella, that she’d cut it off before leaving Boston because they wouldn’t let her bring the umbrella.

Her father had carved her nickname on it.”

Jennifer still had the piece of wood—about two inches long, dark with age, worn smooth.

Carved into it, barely visible, was the word “Ellie.” Lisa compared the carving to the photograph.

They matched perfectly.

Eleanor Hayes Sullivan had carried that piece of wood from Boston to Kansas in 1895, through her adoption, marriage, motherhood, and her entire life.

When she died in 1968 at age 82, she passed it to her daughter Catherine, who passed it to Ruth, who passed it to Jennifer.

“My great-grandmother always said it was the only thing she had from her real family,” Jennifer explained.

“She loved the Muellers, but she never forgot where she came from.

And she never forgot her father had loved her enough to carve her name into his umbrella.”

 

IX.

Rediscovered: A Story for the World

In November 2019, the Massachusetts Historical Society organized an exhibition: “Orphan Train Memories: Lost Children, Found Stories.” Eleanor’s photograph was displayed with the digitally magnified umbrella handle and the piece of carved wood on loan from Jennifer.

The story was told for the first time:

> Eleanor Hayes, orphaned at age nine, photographed holding her father’s umbrella before being sent west.

The umbrella, carved with her father’s initials and nickname, was her last connection to family.

Forced to leave it behind, she secretly cut off the piece bearing her name.

She kept it for 73 years, preserving the only proof she’d once been Ellie—a beloved daughter, not just an orphan.

Over 40,000 people visited the exhibition in six months.

Many were descendants of orphan train riders.

Many cried reading Eleanor’s story.

Jennifer Sullivan Brooks spoke at the opening: “My great-grandmother lived to be 82.

She had a good life, a loving husband, four children, grandchildren, a home.

But she never forgot the terror of being nine, alone, holding her father’s umbrella, knowing she was about to lose the last thing connecting her to her family.

That umbrella wasn’t just an object—it was proof.

Proof that William Hayes had existed.

Proof that he’d loved his daughter.

Proof that Eleanor had once belonged to someone.

When they tried to take that away, she refused.

She cut off a piece and carried it for the rest of her life.

Today, we honor her courage.

We honor her father’s love.

And we remember the 200,000 children like Eleanor who were sent west on orphan trains.

Many of their stories will never be recovered.

But Eleanor’s story survives because of a photograph, a carved umbrella handle, and her refusal to let go.”

 

X.

What Remains: Love Carved in Wood

Eleanor Hayes Sullivan died on March 14, 1968, in Topeka, Kansas.

She was buried next to her husband Frank in Mount Hope Cemetery.

Her headstone reads: “Eleanor Hayes Sullivan, 1886–1968.

Beloved wife, mother, grandmother.

Ellie.”

The carved piece of wood is now permanently displayed at the Massachusetts Historical Society next to Eleanor’s photograph.

And millions have now seen what Eleanor clutched so desperately in 1895: her father’s umbrella, carved with love, held with hope, photographed for posterity.

Sometimes the saddest stories are the ones where love survives even when everything else is lost.

 

Visit

Eleanor’s photograph and the carved wood piece are on display at the Massachusetts Historical Society, Boston.

Learn more about orphan train history and help descendants find their family stories.

Subscribe for more forgotten histories revealed through photography.