Season 5 May Be the LAST! Only Murders Cast Drops Hints, But One Star Isn’t Coming Back…

Move over, ordinary TV dramas—because the trio of the century is back in the spotlight, and fans are losing their minds.

Only Murders in the Building, the Hulu sensation that somehow turned murder, mystery, and New York real estate into a bingeable comedy goldmine, has officially wrapped Season 5… and the universe might never be the same.

Selena Gomez, Steve Martin, and Martin Short, the stars who gave us detective duo vibes we didn’t know we needed, just teased the series’ future in a way that has viewers clutching their popcorn like life depends on it.

First, let’s set the scene.

 

Selena Gomez, the queen of effortless cool, Steve Martin, the living legend whose comedic timing makes angels weep, and Martin Short, the tiny dynamo of laughter, sat down for a chat that has already broken the internet.

And no, they didn’t just talk about fan theories or awkward behind-the-scenes moments—they dropped hints that could change the entire landscape of the show.

According to our fake-but-believable insider: “Selena was coy, Steve smirked like he knew the end of the world was coming, and Martin Short…well, Martin Short just twitched with excitement.

You could feel the tension.

This isn’t your grandma’s sitcom chat—it was a reveal disguised as a casual conversation. ”

Fans immediately erupted online.

Twitter threads exploded with speculation, Reddit communities started analyzing every word like it was the Dead Sea Scrolls, and TikTok users recreated dramatic scenes from the series with captions like: “Did they just hint at the apocalypse of 1230… or the next killer plot twist?”

The internet has officially lost its mind, and honestly, can you blame them? This is the Avengers: Infinity War moment of TV gossip—minus the CGI explosions, plus a whole lot of murder mystery and witty banter.

So, what exactly did the trio say? Well, let’s break it down, with a healthy sprinkle of tabloid exaggeration.

Selena Gomez reportedly teased: “We’ve had so much fun with Season 5, but the story isn’t over.

There are secrets that even we don’t fully understand yet.

” Wait, what? Even the actors don’t fully understand the secrets? Cue fan panic.

One fake TV critic commented: “If the stars themselves are confused, the rest of us are basically doomed.

The series might go full Inception-level on us next. ”

Meanwhile, Steve Martin, who has always been the king of cryptic humor, added: “Well, let’s just say, the building isn’t done with us, and we’re not done with it. ”

Fans immediately interpreted this as everything from new character crossovers, potential spinoffs, and yes, the return of some very mysterious killers.

One fake industry insider said: “Steve’s smirk alone told us more than words could.

 

He’s always teasing chaos.

And I mean real chaos.

We’re talking Season 6 breaking the internet. ”

And then there’s Martin Short, whose eyes literally spark wild theories every time he blinks.

Short reportedly winked during the discussion and said, “Oh, the next season… it’s going to be something you’ll never see coming.

Ever. ”

The line was delivered so casually, yet so dramatically, that the internet exploded into speculation about secret guest stars, shocking betrayals, and maybe even musical numbers.

Because honestly, anything is possible in the world of OMITB.

Of course, fans have already started putting together conspiracy boards.

One viral TikTok, shared by a self-proclaimed “murder board expert,” listed potential plot twists including: new building residents with hidden pasts, double murders, secret alliances, and—brace yourself—an appearance from a celebrity cameo that nobody expected.

Some threads even claim the show might cross over with another mystery series, though that remains purely speculative (and hilarious).

One fake analyst claimed: “We’re seeing the dawn of a television universe, and Only Murders in the Building is the epicenter.

Everyone else is just supporting cast. ”

Social media reactions have been equally dramatic.

Fans are speculating about everything from the final fates of beloved characters to whether Charles, Oliver, and Mabel will survive Season 6 intact.

 

Reddit threads boast headlines like: “Selena Gomez Knew Something We Don’t About the Killer!” and “Steve Martin Smirked—Season 6 Is Already DOOMED.

” Theories range from wild to completely insane, and yes, it’s all being devoured with obsessive enthusiasm.

One thing that keeps fans engaged—and slightly terrified—is the chemistry of the trio.

Selena’s cool, modern wit mixed with Steve’s deadpan genius and Martin Short’s chaotic energy creates a perfect storm of on-screen and off-screen drama.

Fake behind-the-scenes sources suggest that during the discussion, there were moments where all three of them laughed maniacally in ways that fans have already dubbed “apocalypse chuckles. ”

“It was eerie and wonderful at the same time,” said a fabricated producer.

“You could tell they were plotting something that would haunt fandoms for years. ”

And while the actors were careful not to reveal concrete spoilers, their vague hints have already fueled a massive amount of creative speculation.

Fans are dissecting episodes for clues, analyzing props, and rewatching every episode like detectives in training.

A fake media critic summarized it perfectly: “This is genius.

The actors are teasing chaos, the writers are laughing, and we’re all trapped in a web of speculation and obsession.

Brilliant. ”

Meanwhile, some fake TV historians suggest that this could mark a shift in the series itself.

OMITB, after all, has been a delicate balance of comedy, murder mystery, and meta-commentary.

 

Could Season 6 dive into darker territory? Will the building itself become a character? Are there secret messages hidden in every frame that foreshadow the next big twist? Fans aren’t taking chances—they’re rewatching the series frame by frame, screenshotting every suspicious glance and possible murder weapon.

One fake fan blogger even claimed: “I paused the last episode 23 times just to study Steve Martin’s eyebrows.

It’s a cultural phenomenon. ”

The actors’ statements also prompted wild imaginings about new characters.

Could a rival sleuth appear to challenge the main trio? Will the building host a bizarre celebrity murder event? Fans are predicting everything from cameo appearances by actual celebrities to “meta-killer” plotlines where the actors themselves are suspects.

Fake entertainment insiders teased: “The writers love chaos.

The actors love chaos.

Season 6 might break the fourth wall so hard, you’ll need therapy afterward. ”

Even the streaming numbers suggest that Hulu is preparing for an explosion.

Executives are reportedly rubbing their hands together, knowing that even vague hints from Gomez, Martin, and Short can send subscriptions soaring.

A fake marketing insider said: “This is gold.

Tease a little, hint at a lot, and let fans run wild.

It’s the perfect storm for streaming domination. ”

And let’s not forget the emotional attachment fans have to these characters.

Charles, Oliver, and Mabel aren’t just fictional detectives—they’re cultural icons.

 

One fabricated pop culture professor commented: “We’ve reached a point where people are emotionally invested in fictional murders more than real-world politics.

That’s the power of Gomez, Martin, and Short together.

They’ve created a fandom ecosystem that feeds on chaos, speculation, and obsessive analysis. ”

Naturally, the tabloids are having a field day.

Headlines scream: “OMITB Stars TEASE SHOCKING FUTURE—You Won’t Believe What They Said!” and “Selena Gomez, Steve Martin, Martin Short Hint at Secrets That Will Ruin Your Life!” The coverage is over-the-top, dramatic, and perfect for the series’ fanbase—because the lines between reality, fiction, and gossip have never been blurrier.

Of course, nothing is confirmed.

That’s the beauty of this.

By keeping things vague, the stars and the showrunners have created a worldwide frenzy.

Every word, glance, and laugh is being dissected, debated, and memed.

The secrecy fuels engagement, drives discussion, and ensures that Only Murders in the Building stays the hottest show in streaming history.

So, what can fans expect? Will the building host a new, sinister mystery? Will the trio survive multiple plot twists? Could celebrity cameos turn murder-mystery meta? The truth is: nobody knows, and that’s exactly how the creators want it.

Fake insiders say: “We’ve entered an era of television where uncertainty is king.

And with Gomez, Martin, and Short at the helm, fans are going to love the chaos. ”

And let’s be honest, the speculation isn’t just fun—it’s addictive.

 

Fans are already planning watch parties, creating obsessive Reddit timelines, and theorizing about every possible murder weapon, secret message, and cryptic glance.

The series has transcended the screen, becoming a social media and pop culture phenomenon that shows no signs of slowing down.

In the end, Selena Gomez, Steve Martin, and Martin Short have done it again: teased fans mercilessly, hinted at future chaos, and reminded the world why Only Murders in the Building isn’t just a show—it’s an obsession.

Whether the next season delivers new murders, deeper mysteries, or simply more meta jokes, one thing is certain: the fanbase will be here, analyzing every blink, smirk, and cryptic line, ready to turn the building into a virtual crime scene of speculation.

So, buckle up, fans.

The future of Only Murders in the Building is wild, mysterious, and entirely unpredictable.

Selena, Steve, and Martin have only just begun to hint at the madness to come—and we’re all along for the ride.

Popcorn ready? You’ll need it.