The Battle of the Quarterbacks: Why Stephen A. Skeptical About Shedeur Sanders Outshining Jaxson Dart in 2025!

As the NFL season approaches, discussions about the future of young quarterbacks are heating up.

On a recent episode of First Take, the panel delved into the quarterback landscape, specifically focusing on Shedeur Sanders and Jaxson Dart.

Stephen A.Smith raised eyebrows with his skepticism about whether Sanders would see more starts than Dart in the 2025 season.

The conversation kicked off with a look at the upcoming NFL season, which is just 13 days away.

As the analysts discussed various teams’ win totals, the focus quickly shifted to the young quarterbacks.

Jaxson Dart, who has been impressive in preseason games, was highlighted as a potential starter for the New York Giants, while Shedeur Sanders, currently with the Cleveland Browns, faces a more complicated path to starting.

Joe Fortenbaugh, another analyst on the panel, expressed confidence in the Giants’ defense and Dart’s abilities, stating, “I watched him last night. Open my heart to Dart.”

He believes that Dart will be the starter by October and that his performance will help the Giants exceed expectations this season.

Dart’s preseason stats, including a 68% completion rate and a touchdown in every game, have made a strong case for his readiness.

In contrast, the situation for Shedeur Sanders is less clear.

After showing promise in his first preseason game, Sanders was sidelined due to an oblique injury, raising concerns about his immediate future.

The Browns have signed veteran quarterbacks Joe Flacco and Jameis Winston, which complicates Sanders’ chances of starting.

Analyst Chris Canty argued that the Browns have a vested interest in evaluating their young quarterbacks, suggesting that Sanders could see more action as the season progresses.

However, Stephen A. countered Canty’s optimism about Sanders, arguing that the Giants’ coaching staff, led by Brian Daboll, is under pressure to win now.

He believes that Dart will get the nod over Sanders because the Giants are looking for immediate results and cannot afford to wait for Dart to develop.

“Daboll’s job is on the line,” Stephen A. asserted, emphasizing that the urgency to perform will push the Giants to start Dart sooner.

The debate continued as the analysts weighed the strengths and weaknesses of both quarterbacks.

While Dart has shown he can handle the pressure, Stephen A. pointed out that the Giants’ situation is more favorable for Dart to step in and succeed.

Meanwhile, the Browns’ commitment to their veteran quarterbacks could hinder Sanders’ chances of playing time.

Canty maintained that the Browns have no incentive to keep Flacco or Winston in the game if they want to assess their young talent.

He argued that the organization should prioritize figuring out what they have in Sanders and Dylan Gabriel, suggesting that Sanders could ultimately be the first off the bench if Flacco struggles.

The conversation took an interesting turn as Stephen A. and Canty discussed the potential for both quarterbacks to start multiple games this season.

Stephen A. noted that the Browns’ defense, which was expected to be a strength, has shown signs of vulnerability, raising questions about how long Flacco could hold onto the starting job.

On the other hand, Dart’s situation was described as more stable, with a solid supporting cast and a coaching staff eager to see results.

The analysts agreed that both quarterbacks have the potential to shine, but the circumstances surrounding them will play a crucial role in determining who gets more starts.

As the debate heated up, it became clear that the future of both quarterbacks is uncertain, but Dart’s situation appears to be more favorable.

With the Giants looking to make an immediate impact and the Browns still figuring out their quarterback situation, Stephen A.’s skepticism about Sanders outpacing Dart in starts seems well-founded.

Ultimately, the discussion highlighted the unpredictable nature of the NFL and the factors that influence a quarterback’s path to starting.

As the season unfolds, fans will be watching closely to see how both Jaxson Dart and Shedeur Sanders navigate their respective challenges and whether either can emerge as a standout in the league.

With the NFL season just around the corner, the anticipation for these young quarterbacks is palpable.

Will Dart take the reins for the Giants, or will Sanders find his way onto the field for the Browns? Only time will tell, but one thing is certain: the battle for starting jobs is far from over.