Rigged Justice? Menendez Brothers’ Lawyer Blasts Parole Hearings Amid Ongoing Controversy!

The legal saga surrounding Eric and Lyle Menendez has taken a dramatic twist as their longtime attorney, Mark Geragos, publicly condemned the California parole system, asserting that the brothers’ recent hearings were “obviously rigged.”

Speaking on the August 23rd episode of TMZ’s Two Angry Men podcast, Geragos did not hold back in his criticism of the parole proceedings that resulted in both brothers being denied parole.

“It was obviously rigged,” he stated emphatically, suggesting that the outcome was predetermined long before his clients even had the opportunity to present their case.

“Don’t believe me? Talk to any of the family members. The only people who thought it wasn’t rigged were the DA’s office,” he added, highlighting the apparent bias he perceives in the process.

Geragos escalated his accusations, claiming that both the Los Angeles County District Attorney’s Office and the parole board displayed a shocking lack of preparedness.

He described the hearing process as “unbelievable” and likened it more to a “show” than a legitimate legal proceeding.

The attorney emphasized that the board’s reluctance to allow public access to the hearings was revealing, suggesting that transparency could have unveiled significant flaws in the proceedings.

“No one would believe this was happening in the U.S. in 2025,” Geragos remarked, underscoring his belief that the system is failing.

The Menendez brothers, now in their mid-50s, have spent an astonishing 36 years behind bars after being convicted in 1996 for the brutal murders of their parents, José and Mary Louise “Kitty” Menendez, in their Beverly Hills home in 1989.

This high-profile case has captivated the public for decades, generating numerous documentaries, dramatizations, and heated debates over whether the brothers acted out of cold-blooded greed or as a desperate response to years of alleged abuse.

Despite Geragos’s passionate claims, the parole board ultimately issued three-year denials for both Eric and Lyle Menendez.

This means that the brothers will remain incarcerated, although they will have the option to request an administrative review of the board’s decision as early as next year.

The controversy surrounding the latest parole hearings highlights the Menendez case as one of the most polarizing narratives in American true crime history.

While some view the brothers as manipulative killers who plotted to inherit their family’s fortune, others see them as tragic figures who endured horrific abuse before reaching a breaking point.

Supporters of the Menendez brothers argue that after nearly four decades behind bars, the siblings have shown remorse, rehabilitation, and stability—qualities that parole boards are supposed to consider heavily.

However, detractors maintain that the heinous nature of their crimes should warrant life imprisonment without parole.

Geragos’s allegations of a “rigged” process are likely to reignite conversations about transparency within California’s parole system, especially in high-profile cases where public opinion and political pressures can significantly influence outcomes.

Whether his remarks will affect the brothers’ next review remains uncertain, but one thing is clear: even 36 years after the shocking crime that gripped the nation, the Menendez brothers’ story continues to provoke debate and intrigue.

As the legal battle unfolds, the Menendez brothers remain emblematic of the complexities of justice, abuse, and the quest for redemption in a system that many believe is in dire need of reform.

With every new development, the public remains captivated, eager to see how this notorious case will evolve and whether the Menendez brothers will ever find a path to freedom.

As Geragos continues to challenge the fairness of the parole system, the Menendez brothers’ plight serves as a stark reminder of the ongoing struggles within the American justice system, particularly for those whose stories have become intertwined with the public consciousness.

The questions surrounding their case are far from settled, and as the narrative continues to unfold, the Menendez brothers will undoubtedly remain at the center of one of the most contentious discussions in true crime history.