‘Giants’ Preseason Shockwaves: Who Rose to the Occasion and Who Fell Flat?

What a preseason it has been for the New York Giants! Finishing with a 3-0 record, the Giants not only won their games but did so in a dominating fashion, outscoring their opponents 107-47.

The highlight of this stellar performance was undoubtedly their final game against the New England Patriots, where they delivered a resounding 42-10 victory.

Beating the Patriots is always a sweet taste for fans, but the Giants’ success goes deeper than just the scoreboard.

While it’s essential to take preseason records with a grain of salt—after all, the 2008 Detroit Lions went 4-0 in the preseason and then proceeded to go 0-16 in the regular season—there are still valuable insights to be gained from these games.

As the Giants reflect on their performance, here are the biggest winners and losers from an exhilarating preseason.

 

NY Giants Are Among Teams Most Likely to Improve in 2025 per New Analysis

 

One of the most significant revelations of the preseason has been the explosive performance of the Giants’ offense under offensive coordinator Mike Kafka.

After a challenging previous season where the Giants averaged a meager 16.1 points per game, the team has turned things around dramatically.

Kafka’s return to calling plays has proven to be a game-changer.

The Giants scored over 30 points in every preseason game, a remarkable feat that showcases the newfound effectiveness and energy of the offense.

While it’s easy to dismiss preseason success as inconsequential, the improvement is undeniable and bodes well for the regular season.

 

Mike Kafka is in demand: Inside the Giants OC's meteoric rise to NFL head  coach candidate - The Athletic

 

Rookie quarterback Jaxson Dart has emerged as a beacon of hope for the Giants.

The 22-year-old signal caller brought a collective sigh of relief to Big Blue Nation with his impressive performance throughout the preseason.

Dart completed 32 of 47 passes for 372 yards, throwing three touchdown passes and rushing for another, all while not committing a single turnover.

His selection at No. 25 had initially been met with skepticism, but Dart has proven that he’s more than capable of handling the pressure.

The Giants had a plan for him, and it seems to be paying off, signaling the start of what could be a promising career.

 

Should Saints take Jaxson Dart? Or should they draft some protection? -  Mississippi Today

 

Not every player has basked in the glory of the Giants’ successful preseason.

Center John Michael Schmitz has faced significant struggles, raising concerns about his development and performance.

Throughout training camp and the preseason, Schmitz has failed to make a positive impact, leading to questions about whether he can meet the team’s expectations for improved offensive line play.

For a team that desperately needs a solid offensive line, Schmitz’s performance has been disappointing, and it may be time for the Giants to consider a contingency plan.

 

John Michael Schmitz embodies 'smart, tough, dependable'

 

While the offense has garnered much of the attention, the Giants’ defense has also been a significant winner this preseason.

They have effectively stifled opposing offenses, showcasing a blend of aggressive play and strategic execution.

The defensive unit has not only limited scoring opportunities but has also created turnovers, which are crucial for winning games.

With the defense stepping up, the Giants look poised to become a well-rounded team capable of competing in the upcoming season.

 

New York Giants: Landon Collins named NFC Defensive Player of the month for  November

 

Running back Saquon Barkley has also been a standout performer during the preseason.

After battling injuries in previous seasons, Barkley has shown flashes of his former self, demonstrating speed, agility, and power on the field.

His ability to make explosive plays will be vital for the Giants’ offense as they aim to build on their preseason success.

If Barkley can stay healthy, he could be a game-changer for the Giants this season.

 

The Pros and Cons Of The Eagles Signing Saquon Barkley - 97.5 The Fanatic

 

While Jaxson Dart has shined, the backup quarterback situation remains a concern.

The Giants need to ensure they have a reliable option behind Dart if needed, but the performances of the other quarterbacks have not inspired confidence.

Injuries can happen at any moment, and having a solid backup is crucial for any team’s success.

The Giants will need to address this position before the regular season begins.

 

Giants tie mark with 4th win as underdog through first 6 games - ESPN

 

Lastly, the Giants’ special teams have not been without their flaws.

Inconsistencies in kicking and coverage have raised eyebrows, and these issues could prove costly during the regular season.

While the offense and defense appear to be on the rise, the special teams unit must improve to ensure the Giants can capitalize on their overall momentum.

In conclusion, the New York Giants have had an exciting preseason filled with highs and lows.

With a perfect record and standout performances from key players, they’ve set the stage for what could be a thrilling regular season.

 

Giants among youngest teams in NFL

 

However, the team must address its weaknesses, particularly on the offensive line and special teams, if they hope to build on their success and compete in the upcoming season.

As they prepare for the challenges ahead, fans can only hope that the positive trends continue and that the Giants return to their winning ways.