Baker Mayfield & Mark Andrews: From College Teammates to Trade Possibility

When Baker Mayfield and Mark Andrews shared the field at the University of Oklahoma from 2015 to 2017, they were more than just teammates; they were a dynamic duo that redefined offensive prowess in college football.

Together, they led the Sooners to three Big 12 titles and two College Football Playoff appearances, forging a connection that many fans still reminisce about today.

Now, nearly a decade later, rumors are swirling around the NFL that the Tampa Bay Buccaneers are considering a bold move to reunite this explosive pair.

Could this trade be the key to revitalizing the Buccaneers’ offense?

The Rumor Ignites

Recent reports from various NFL insiders suggest that the Baltimore Ravens may be entertaining offers for their star tight end, Mark Andrews.

General Manager Eric DeCosta’s cryptic statement, “I never know what’s going to happen,” has only fueled speculation that Andrews could be on the trading block before the deadline.

With the emergence of Isaiah Likely as a capable replacement, coupled with Andrews’ substantial cap hit, the Ravens may be inclined to make a change.

Meanwhile, the Buccaneers find themselves in a competitive NFC South, desperately seeking a playmaker to enhance Baker Mayfield’s offensive capabilities.

Why This Trade Makes Perfect Sense for Tampa Bay

Built-In Chemistry: Mayfield and Andrews have years of experience working together, which translates to a natural on-field rhythm.Their established timing and trust could elevate Tampa Bay’s passing game to new heights almost immediately.
Red-Zone Dominance: Mark Andrews has consistently proven to be one of the NFL’s most effective scorers in the red zone.Pairing him with Mayfield’s aggressive playing style could create nightmares for opposing defenses, particularly in high-stakes situations.
Locker Room Leadership: Both players bring a level of intensity and accountability that head coach Todd Bowles values.Their shared experience and competitive nature could foster a more cohesive locker room environment.

Projected Trade Value Simulation

In assessing potential trade packages, one can look at recent elite tight end trades for context.

For instance, Darren Waller was traded to the New York Giants, and T.J.Hockenson was dealt to the Minnesota Vikings.

A reasonable package for Andrews might include:

To Baltimore: 2026 2nd-round pick + conditional 4th-rounder + TE Cade Otton
To Tampa Bay: TE Mark Andrews

This deal would provide the Ravens with significant cap relief (approximately $11 million), a young tight end in Cade Otton, and valuable draft picks.

For Tampa Bay, acquiring Andrews would mean gaining an immediate game-changer and Mayfield’s preferred target.

Strategic Fit: The “Sooner Connection” Effect

Offensive coordinator Dave Canales has a clear vision for the Buccaneers’ offense, emphasizing quick reads, high-percentage throws, and exploiting middle-field spacing.

Andrews excels in these areas, and his elite route-running against linebackers would create opportunities for other star receivers like Chris Godwin and Mike Evans to stretch the field.

An NFL scout recently told Pro Football Network, “If you give Mayfield a tight end he already trusts, Tampa’s ceiling jumps by at least a touchdown per game.”

This kind of impact could be crucial for a team looking to establish itself in a wide-open division.

The Risk Factor

However, every trade comes with its risks.

Andrews has faced durability issues in recent years, suffering from multiple lower-body injuries that raise concerns about his long-term viability.

At 30 years old, he is entering the twilight of his prime, and Tampa Bay’s salary cap situation would tighten significantly, limiting future flexibility.

If the Buccaneers miscalculate this move, they could be sacrificing depth and future assets for a short-term boost.

Verdict: Should the Bucs Make the Call?

The answer is a resounding yes.

In a division that lacks clear dominance, taking bold steps could be the defining factor for the Buccaneers in the NFC South.

Reuniting Mayfield and Andrews isn’t merely a nostalgic gesture; it’s a tactical decision that could reshape the team’s offensive identity.

The connection that once electrified the field in Norman, Oklahoma, may very well hold the key to revitalizing Tampa Bay’s struggling offense.

However, as is the case in the NFL, every move comes with a price.

If the Buccaneers fail to act on this opportunity, they may soon find themselves haunted by the question: “What if the magic of 2017 could’ve saved 2025?”

With the trade deadline looming, the clock is ticking.

Will the Buccaneers seize the moment and make a move that could change the trajectory of their season? Only time will tell, but the prospect of a Baker Mayfield–Mark Andrews reunion is certainly one to watch.