“Pay Us What You Owe Us”: Why Kelsey Plum Says WNBA All-Stars’ Silent Protest Could Be a Turning Point in the League’s Labor Battle

On Saturday night, beneath the glittering lights of the 2025 WNBA All-Star Game, something happened that transcended basketball. As players from both teams stepped onto the court for warmups, all eyes fell not on their footwork or jump shots—but on the bold black t-shirts stretched across their warmup gear.

Printed in large, white block letters: “Pay us what you owe us.”

It wasn’t a marketing stunt or a halftime gimmick. It was a message. A united front. A collective cry from a league of women athletes who have, for decades, fought for recognition—not just for their talent, but for their paychecks.

Kelsey Plum, star guard for the Los Angeles Sparks, called the moment “very powerful” during the postgame press conference. She explained that while not all players knew ahead of time, the idea of showing solidarity had come from a players-only meeting that morning.

It wasn’t about individual names or rivalries—it was about standing together on the biggest stage of the season, making sure that labor negotiations didn’t stay behind closed doors.

The WNBA players’ call for fair pay is nothing new. But in 2025, with stars like Caitlin Clark and Angel Reese injecting massive public interest and social media traction into the league, the timing couldn’t be more symbolic.

Yet the challenge is steep. Even the most devoted fans of the WNBA would have to admit that the league’s revenue numbers pale in comparison to those of its male counterpart.

Under the current Collective Bargaining Agreement (CBA), WNBA players are entitled to 25% of league profits—but only if certain revenue thresholds are met. NBA players, on the other hand, receive an automatic 50-50 split of revenue.

For many players, that math just doesn’t sit right. Consider this: the lowest rookie-scale contract in the WNBA over four years comes in at $285,136 total—about $71,000 annually.

Meanwhile, the highest-earning players max out at just under $250,000. Compare that to the NBA’s rookie minimum, which is north of $1 million per year. And the superstars? They rake in tens of millions annually.

Of course, critics argue the economics don’t add up. And they’re not wrong—at least not yet. Reports estimate that the WNBA has operated at an average loss of $10 million per year since its inception.

Last season alone, the league posted a $40 million deficit, better than the $50 million loss initially projected—but still a major concern for those managing the bottom line.

Popular streamer Adin Ross didn’t hold back, blasting the protest on social media. “Unless you’re Caitlin Clark, you shouldn’t ever be able to wear a shirt that says ‘Pay us what you owe us,’” he said in a viral clip. “Your league makes no f–king revenue. It’s probably a write-off for the NBA.”

Even fans online joined in, with one “X” (formerly Twitter) user joking that if the league lost $50 million this year, then each of the WNBA’s 153 players technically owe the league $326,797—flipping the shirt’s slogan into darkly comic irony: “They need to pay what they owe.”

Still, mocking aside, the frustration among players is palpable—and understandable. This isn’t just about money. It’s about visibility. Respect. A seat at the table.

And it’s not as simple as revenue vs. salary. Endorsements have become a major lifeline for players, especially the newer generation.

Caitlin Clark acknowledged that endorsement deals have given some players a buffer, but emphasized that shouldn’t be the default solution. “We should be paid more,” she said, echoing sentiments across the locker room.

The optimism lies in the league’s potential. With record-breaking college stars entering the league, television deals expanding, and fan engagement on the rise, the WNBA seems poised for its breakout era. The question now is whether its compensation structures—and its owners—can keep up with that momentum.

Can a league running a $40 million deficit afford to raise salaries? Technically, no. But can it afford not to, if it wants to retain its most valuable assets—its players? That’s the real debate. And it’s only heating up.

What’s certain is this: the All-Star warmup wasn’t just a t-shirt moment. It was a flashpoint. A reminder that the future of the WNBA isn’t just about points scored or games won. It’s about power, voice, and the price of being taken seriously in professional sports.

As fans cheered and cameras flashed, the players stood silently, but their shirts shouted the message loud and clear: we’re not just athletes—we’re workers. And we want what we’re worth.

.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.