🔥 “They Betrayed, Bullied, and Broke Me” — Bewitched Star Elizabeth Montgomery Names 6 Men She Never Forgave 😢

Elizabeth Montgomery is best remembered as Samantha Stephens, the beautiful, whip-smart witch who enchanted viewers week after week on Bewitched.

But off-screen, her life was anything but a fairytale.

thumbnail

Known for keeping her personal life fiercely private, Montgomery rarely aired her grievances publicly.

Yet those closest to her say that by the time she turned 62 — just three years before losing her battle with cancer — she decided it was time to speak her truth.

In a late-night conversation reportedly shared with a lifelong friend, she named six men who caused her the most emotional pain, professional betrayal, and lasting resentment during her life in Hollywood.

1.William Asher (Her Ex-Husband & Bewitched Producer)
Their marriagebegan with passion and promise, but it didn’t take long for the cracks to show.

William Asher - IMDb

Asher, who directed and produced most of Bewitched, was described by Elizabeth as “a man who couldn’t separate love from control.

” While they created one of the most iconic shows of all time together, Asher allegedly micromanaged every detail of her performance, from her wardrobe to her voice inflection.

Insiders claim he was obsessed with molding her into a picture-perfect TV wife — on screen and off.

After their divorce, Elizabeth reportedly said, “I lost myself in that marriage.

I played a character on set and at home.

2.Dick York (The Original Darrin)

Dick York - IMDb
While many fans loved the chemistry between Samantha and the first Darrin, the relationship behind the scenes was far more strained.

Dick York, plagued by chronic pain and addiction issues, often showed up to set late or not at all.

Montgomery was said to be sympathetic at first — but her patience eventually wore thin.

“I admired his talent, but his unpredictability made every day hell,” she reportedly said.

Sources close to the production claim that York’s erratic behavior led to screaming matches and shutdowns during filming, leaving Elizabeth emotionally drained.

3.Dick Sargent (The Second Darrin)
When York was replaced by Dick Sargent, fans expected a smoother ride.

But according to Montgomery, things got even worse.

Happy Birthday Dick Sargent! 5 Things You Didn't Know About the 'Bewitched'  Star

Though Sargent later came out as gay and remained a friend in later years, their working relationship during Bewitched was, according to her, “cold, awkward, and robotic.

” She felt he resented her status as the show’s star and often clashed with her over comedic direction.

“It was like working with a wall,” she allegedly told her confidant.

“No spark.

No support.

Just ego.

4.Her Father, Robert Montgomery
This one cuts the deepest.

A Hollywood star in his own right, Robert Montgomery was never warm or encouraging with his daughter.

Elizabeth Montgomery and her father Robert Montgomery...

Elizabeth once described him as “emotionally absent, critical, and impossible to please.

” Despite her fame, he reportedly dismissed her acting career as “lightweight TV fluff” compared to his film legacy.

Sources say she spent much of her adult life trying to earn his approval — approval that never came.

“He taught me how to act,” she reportedly said, “but never how to feel loved.

5.A Powerful Studio Executive (Unnamed)
Montgomery also revealed the existence of a high-ranking network executive who, she claimed, tried to derail her career after she rejected his advances.

“He thought he owned me because I was under contract,” she said.

After turning him down, she allegedly noticed a sudden shift in the tone of media coverage, a reduction in promotion for her projects, and unexplained cancellations of roles.

“He didn’t just punish me — he made sure everyone else stayed silent,” she reportedly confided.

Though she never publicly named him, those familiar with her story believe he was a major figure at ABC in the late ’60s.

6.A Co-Star From a 1980s TV Movie (Possibly Ed Asner)
In one of her final dramatic roles, Montgomery starred alongside a gruff, award-winning actor in a made-for-TV movie — and the experience reportedly left her fuming.

Actor Ed Asner, TV's blustery Lou Grant, dies at 91

While she never officially named the actor, she described him as “condescending, sexist, and constantly undermining my scenes.

” He reportedly rolled his eyes during her close-ups, questioned her acting choices, and dismissed her as a “sitcom has-been.

” For someone who had fought hard to be taken seriously as a dramatic actress, the experience was devastating.

“He made me feel like I’d never escape Samantha,” she said bitterly.

These six men, according to Montgomery, shaped much of the private pain behind her public success.

For decades, she wore the perfect smile, charmed audiences, and embodied elegance — all while quietly enduring power plays, betrayals, and emotional wounds that rarely healed.

By the time she revealed her truth, she wasn’t looking for revenge — just release.

In her final years, Elizabeth Montgomery began distancing herself from Hollywood entirely.

She focused on activism, her children, and reconnecting with her true self — far from the soundstages and scripts that once defined her.

Those close to her say revealing this list was part of her healing process, a way to finally say what she couldn’t for most of her life: “Being bewitched wasn’t always a blessing.

Sometimes, it was a curse I couldn’t escape.

Now, as these untold stories come to light, fans are seeing the real Elizabeth — not just the magical woman who twitched her nose and made the world smile, but the complex, battle-hardened survivor who finally, fearlessly, spoke her truth.