🔥 Red Carpet DRAMA?! Sarah Michelle Gellar Accused of Throwing Major Shade at Jennifer Love Hewitt — What REALLY Happened!? 💄

It was supposed to be a nostalgic reunion: two queens of ’90s horror, Sarah Michelle Gellar and Jennifer Love Hewitt, stepping onto the same red carpet for the first time in years.

The event? A Hollywood screening of I Know What You Did Last Summer: 25th Anniversary Special, packed with stars, press, and adoring fans hoping to see the iconic duo embrace, reminisce, and relive their horror legacy.

But what they got instead was an icy red carpet interaction that has sparked immediate feud rumors—and left social media completely unhinged.

According to fans and eagle-eyed reporters on the scene, it all went down in a matter of seconds—but it was enough.

Gellar, looking stunning in a sleek black power suit, was making her way down the press line when Jennifer Love Hewitt, dressed in a striking red gown, appeared just a few feet away.

Cameras flashed.

Fans screamed.And then.nothing.

Witnesses say Gellar looked directly in Hewitt’s direction, gave a brief smirk—or was it a sneer?—then turned her back and continued walking.

No hug.

No wave.

Not even eye contact.

It was a blink-and-you’ll-miss-it moment—but trust fans, they did not miss it.

“Did anyone else just see Sarah Michelle Gellar SNUB Jennifer Love Hewitt live on the red carpet!?” one fan tweeted, instantly racking up thousands of likes and shares.

Another wrote: “That was stone-cold.

She looked right at her and kept moving.

What is going on between them??”

Clips of the moment began circulating on TikTok within minutes, with users slowing down the footage, analyzing body language, and adding dramatic soundtracks to heighten the tension.

“This is giving Regina George vs.Cady Heron,” one user joked.

Others weren’t laughing.

“This feels personal,” one commenter wrote.

“You don’t shade someone that hard by accident.

So what exactly happened—and is there a real feud brewing beneath the Hollywood glam?

Theories are flying.

Some fans believe it’s long-standing professional tension, dating back to their careers in the late ’90s, when both actresses were fighting for dominance as America’s go-to scream queen.

While Gellar was slaying vampires as Buffy Summers and co-starring in box office hits like Cruel Intentions, Hewitt was carving her own path with Party of Five and Can’t Hardly Wait.

And, of course, both starred in I Know What You Did Last Summer, a massive horror hit that put them side-by-side—but, according to insiders, never particularly close.

“Let’s just say there was mutual respect, not friendship,” one industry source who worked on the film said.

“They were professionals, but not exactly hanging out between takes.

Adding fuel to the fire? Fans have resurfaced past interviews where Gellar seemed to downplay the significance of I Know What You Did Last Summer, calling it “a fun moment” but “not my defining work.

” Meanwhile, Hewitt has consistently credited the film as a turning point in her career and spoken warmly of her co-stars—including Gellar, even as recently as last year.

“She was incredible to work with,” Hewitt said in an Entertainment Tonight interview.

“I always admired her intensity and commitment.

So was the red carpet moment just a misread—a product of flashing cameras and tight schedules? Not everyone’s buying it.

Body language expert Erika Matthis weighed in on the viral clip, saying: “The way Gellar briefly glanced toward Hewitt, then immediately adjusted her posture and turned away, suggests a conscious decision to avoid interaction.

It wasn’t a coincidence.

It was a choice.

Meanwhile, reps for both actresses have declined to comment—a move that has only added to the online frenzy.

The drama hasn’t stopped fans from taking sides.

Twitter and TikTok are now divided between #TeamSarah and #TeamJennifer, with users revisiting old interviews, red carpet photos, and even comparing outfits from past events.

One viral TikTok accused Gellar of “always acting like she’s above her co-stars,” while another called Hewitt “the true queen of the scream era.

”

As the internet continues to obsess, one thing is crystal clear: this red carpet encounter was not the feel-good reunion fans were hoping for—it was a masterclass in subtle celebrity shade.

Whether it’s a real feud, a media misunderstanding, or just a moment of bad timing, the tension between Sarah Michelle Gellar and Jennifer Love Hewitt has become the hottest gossip in Hollywood.

And if the whispers are true, we may only be seeing the beginning of a very public unraveling of a long-hidden rivalry.

Stay tuned—this story isn’t dying down anytime soon.