2025: Where Are They Now? The Cast of The Chosen and the Price They Paid

The success of The Chosen is undeniable.

What began as a simple retelling of the life of Jesus Christ quickly transformed into a global phenomenon, with millions of viewers tuning in for each episode.

But behind the iconic portrayals of biblical figures like Jesus, Mary Magdalene, Peter, and Matthew, lies a deeper, more personal story.

The actors who brought these characters to life have faced challenges both on and off the screen, some of which have reshaped their lives forever.

As of 2025, these actors are living very different realities, and their stories are as compelling as the ones they tell on screen.

In this article, we explore the hidden costs of fame, the personal battles, and the surprising transformations of The Chosen cast.

Jonathan Roumie: The Actor Who Played Jesus

When Jonathan Roumie was cast as Jesus, he was stepping into a role that would become far more than just acting—it would be a lifelong mission.

Before The Chosen, Roumie’s career was struggling.

He had worked in voice-over, commercials, and small roles, but nothing that gave him stability.

At one point, Roumie admitted he was so broke he prayed for help—and the next day, he received the call for The Chosen.

But playing Jesus didn’t just change Roumie’s career—it altered his entire life.

He went from being an obscure actor to a global figure almost overnight.

Fans lined up for hours to meet him, and many cried just by being in his presence.

Some even asked him to bless their children or confessed their sins to him as if he were the actual Savior.

While this adoration was touching, it was also overwhelming.

The danger of playing Jesus is that people start to blur the lines between the actor and the character.

Roumie has shared in interviews how he constantly has to remind people—and himself—that he is not Jesus.

The weight of this pressure has made him question how he carries the role, but he continues to do so with both reverence and exhaustion.

In 2025, Roumie remains busier than ever, filming new seasons of The Chosen while also speaking at faith-based rallies around the world.

However, the demands of fame and the role he plays have taken their toll.

His personal struggles with loneliness, pride, and the expectations placed on him have made him weary.

But he has also become a voice for young people searching for meaning in an anxious world.

Roumie has admitted that his role in The Chosen is not just about acting—it’s a mission.

Yet, he carries that mission with a burden bigger than himself.

And despite everything, Roumie continues to walk this challenging path, deeply aware of the impact his portrayal of Christ has on audiences.

Shahar Isaac: The Man Behind Peter

Shahar Isaac, the actor behind Simon Peter, portrays a character full of emotion, strength, and vulnerability.

Peter’s fiery and passionate personality resonates with fans, making him one of the standout characters in The Chosen.

However, Isaac’s own life is far more quiet and reserved than the character he plays on screen.

Isaac, unlike Roumie, has chosen to keep a low profile.

He doesn’t give many interviews, and he rarely attends large fan events.

While other actors in the series embrace the limelight, Isaac prefers to remain in the background, focusing on his craft.

His decision to keep his private life hidden speaks to his desire to protect his identity from the fame that comes with his role.

Isaac’s career before The Chosen was fairly low-key.

He had appeared in small roles and trained in theater, but it wasn’t until he played Simon Peter that his life truly changed.

Suddenly, Isaac’s face was known in over 100 countries, from Brazil to South Korea.

But with this fame came a new set of challenges.

Isaac has spoken rarely about the overwhelming attention he receives and has hinted that it can be suffocating at times.

Despite his success with The Chosen, Isaac has remained selective in his career choices.

He continues to play Peter but keeps his presence in Hollywood at a distance.

His refusal to engage in self-promotion has made it harder for him to secure mainstream roles, but those close to him say he is content with the balance he has found.

Isaac’s performance as Peter, raw and real, continues to be one of the most loved aspects of The Chosen.

Elizabeth Tabish: The Woman Who Played Mary Magdalene

Elizabeth Tabish’s portrayal of Mary Magdalene was so raw, so full of pain and redemption, that it felt more real than acting.

Fans were moved by her depiction of a woman broken, haunted, and eventually healed by the grace of Christ.

But what fans didn’t know was that Tabish’s own struggles mirrored the character she played on screen.

Before The Chosen, Tabish had faced rejection after rejection.

Her career in acting seemed to be going nowhere, and she battled with depression as she struggled to make ends meet.

She was ready to give up acting altogether when the role of Mary Magdalene came her way.

Little did she know, this role would change her life.

Tabish has openly shared how playing Mary forced her to confront her own struggles with self-worth.

The pain her character felt on screen was something she understood deeply, and it became a cathartic experience for her.

Fans have reached out to her, saying that her performance saved their lives by showing them that God sees them, too.

However, fame hasn’t erased her own battles.

Tabish has continued to speak openly about her struggles with mental health and her journey to find peace.

As of 2025, she balances her acting career with advocacy, using her platform to raise awareness about mental health and the importance of honesty in a world where so many hide their struggles.

Paris Patel: The Actor Who Brought Matthew to Life

Paris Patel’s portrayal of Matthew in The Chosen struck a chord with audiences.

Matthew was awkward, meticulous, and different from the other disciples, making him relatable to many viewers.

But behind the character of Matthew is Paris Patel, a man who understands what it feels like to be on the outside, looking in.

As a South Asian actor in Hollywood, Patel faced a wall of stereotypes.

For years, the only roles available to him were in the background, as tech support workers or comedic sidekicks.

He longed for meaningful storytelling, but Hollywood rarely gave him the chance.

Then came The Chosen.

Playing Matthew was a breakthrough for Patel.

The role was deeply personal to him, as he understood the character’s outsider status.

But fame has come with its own challenges.

Patel, like Isaac, has chosen to keep a low profile.

While The Chosen has propelled his career, he has remained selective in his projects, staying away from the typical Hollywood limelight.

Patel’s decision to stay out of the mainstream media spotlight has made his career quieter than expected.

But for fans who meet him, he remains humble, polite, and thoughtful, just like Matthew.

His quiet journey, much like his character, is one of searching for belonging and meaning in a world that often overlooks those who don’t fit in.

The Price of Fame: Lessons from The Chosen Cast

As The Chosen continues to break records and touch lives worldwide, the cast members’ journeys remind us that fame comes at a cost.

Jonathan Roumie, Shahar Isaac, Elizabeth Tabish, and Paris Patel have all paid a price for their roles.

Whether it’s the weight of playing Jesus or the struggle of balancing personal life with public expectations, each actor carries their character’s burden with grace and humility.

In 2025, the cast of The Chosen continues to inspire, not just through their performances, but through their personal stories of faith, sacrifice, and resilience.

Their experiences remind us that faith is a gift, but also a cross to bear—one that, like their performances, requires sacrifice, humility, and the courage to stay true to oneself.