QB Battles Decided: Will the Colts, Browns, and Saints Rise or Fall in 2025?

The dust has finally settled on the starting quarterback battles that captivated fans during training camp, revealing some expected outcomes.

Let’s dive into the decisions made by three teams: the Indianapolis Colts, Cleveland Browns, and New Orleans Saints.

Starting with the Indianapolis Colts, the biggest surprise was not the decision itself but the player who emerged victorious.

Daniel Jones has been named the starting quarterback, beating out rookie Anthony Richardson Sr. for the job.

Richardson, despite his youth and potential, may still see action during the season, but for now, Jones’ selection provides a boost to the Colts’ pass catchers.

Players like Josh Downs, Michael Pittman Jr., and rookie tight end Tyler Warren should benefit from Jones’ experience and ability to distribute the ball effectively.

Even running back Jonathan Taylor is likely to see an increase in dump-off passes, which could enhance his fantasy value.

However, if and when Richardson takes the field, there could be a downgrade in the passing game unless he shows significant improvement.

The Colts are banking on Jones to stabilize the offense while they groom Richardson for future success.

Moving to the Cleveland Browns, another veteran has emerged as the starter.

Joe Flacco has been named the starting quarterback over Kenny Pickett and rookies Dillon Gabriel and Shedeur Sanders.

Initially, it seemed like a two-horse race between Flacco and Sanders, but injuries sidelined Sanders during training camp, giving Flacco the edge.

Sanders is set to play in the preseason finale, providing him with a final opportunity to prove he’s ready to step in if Flacco falters or gets injured.

Right now, the fantasy community isn’t buzzing about the Browns’ offense, but there are still key players to consider.

Jerry Jeudy and David Njoku are likely to soak up the majority of targets, along with rookie Cedric Tillman.

The backfield may turn into a three-headed monster with Jerome Ford and rookies Quinshon Judkins and Dylan Sampson.

While Flacco may not be the most dynamic option, the offense could see more upside if a younger player like Sanders were starting.

Lastly, we turn to the New Orleans Saints, who have yet to officially announce their starting quarterback.

However, it appears that Spencer Rattler has won the job, as he’s set to start the preseason finale—often a strong indicator of being the QB1.

As long as Rattler performs well and rookie Tyler Shough doesn’t outshine him, we can expect the South Carolina product to lead the offense in 2025.

Despite this potential, there’s still a cloud of uncertainty surrounding the Saints’ offense.

Kellen Moore’s reputation as a play-caller offers some hope, but it’s hard to fully trust the offense under Rattler’s leadership.

Alvin Kamara remains a solid RB2 option with an average draft position (ADP) of 43.9 on Yahoo, while Chris Olave could see a significant number of targets if he stays healthy.

Rashid Shaheed is generating sleeper hype, but his effectiveness will depend on whether Rattler or Shough can deliver the ball downfield accurately.

In another noteworthy development, the Los Angeles Rams are monitoring the health of their veteran quarterback, Matthew Stafford.

Stafford returned to practice after dealing with a back injury that has been the focus of attention throughout training camp.

His return signals that he’s likely to start the season healthy, but caution is warranted.

Given Stafford’s age and the nature of his injury, one hard hit or sack could bring the issue back to the forefront.

Fantasy managers must weigh the risks when investing high draft capital in players like Puka Nacua (ADP of 13.3) and Davante Adams (ADP of 41.6).

Adams appears to be the safer choice at his current ADP, while Nacua’s injury history raises concerns.

Without Stafford, the Rams’ passing attack could struggle significantly, especially with Jimmy Garoppolo potentially stepping in.

However, with a brilliant offensive mind like Sean McVay at the helm, there’s still a chance for the Rams to succeed, regardless of who is under center.

In summary, the resolution of these quarterback battles has significant implications for the respective teams and their fantasy football prospects.

The Colts are banking on Daniel Jones to lead their offense, while the Browns hope Joe Flacco can provide stability.

In New Orleans, Spencer Rattler’s emergence as the starter could reshape the Saints’ offensive dynamics.

As we approach the start of the season, these developments will be critical for fantasy managers to consider as they finalize their rosters.

Stay tuned for more updates as the preseason wraps up and the regular season looms on the horizon!